Columbus V900: an in-depth review

Posted by Kevin Jaako

Sun, 01/04/2009 - 21:46


Columbus v900 review - Blog-Shmog.com

I was recently given the opportunity to be one of the first GPS-bloggers to get my hands on the Columbus v900 Bluetooth Datalogger. (thanks to my friends at buyGPSnow.com) I spent the last month with the v900, evaluating its build quality, battery performance, usability, functionality and data accuracy. The v900 is a very cool little unit, featuring a 51 channel MTK chipset, an internal 1000mAh Li-Poly battery, Bluetooth, a microSD card slot and even a built in microphone for recording and geo-tagging voice memos. It's all housed in a very tiny, very sleek stainless steel & polycarbonate shell.

Form, Design & Aesthetics

Columbus is gaining a reputation for exceptional industrial design and the v900 is no exception. The Columbus v900 is VERY small. Sit the v900 next to any other GPS device on the planet and you'll instantly appreciate the engineering that went into getting all its functionality into such a small, elegant package.

The front face of the v900 is cut from an almost mirror-like glossy black polycarbonate plastic, housing three status LEDs and a giant circular waypoint button. The jet-black front face matches up perfectly with the matte stainless-steel backplate and helps make the v900 a very solid and robust little device.

On the top edge of the device you'll find a mini-USB port & the power button, on the side: the voice-memo button and finally, on the bottom: the lanyard attachment and microSD card slot. The Columbus v900 scores major points from me for being by far the most bad-ass looking GPS datalogger on the planet, hands down.

Features & Functionality

Looks may be the Columbus v900's strong-point, but functionality is where it really counts -and sadly, this is where the v900 looses a few key points. Let's begin with what's missing; the v900 has two major faults. The one and only way to download your data from the (max 2Gb) microSD card is by ejecting it and plugging it into a card reader on your computer. It doesn't download over Bluetooth, but more surprisingly it doesn't even download over USB! Big miss here, Columbus!!! This is by far the biggest “oops” that should be at the top of the list for a 2.0 release of the v900.

The next major oops for the Columbus v900 is its non-standard log file format. The v900 saves its log files in a modified universal CSV format, making it illegible to both GPSbabel and GPSVisualizer. You have to convert the CSV files to KML format using the TimeAlbum software provided before use in GPSbabel. (if anyone knows of any 3rd party conversion software that works with v900 CSV log files, please let me know) The silver lining here is that TimeAlbum is java-based, so it's cross-platform and it's surprisingly not a bad piece of software!

Columbus v900 features
Columbus v900 features: An impressive list of features for such a small and compact device. Image courtesy of buyGPSnow.com.

That's pretty much all I have to complain about regarding the v900, so with that out of the way, it's on to the good stuff...

The v900 logs all the right things: {lat, lon, ele, speed, heading, hdop, vdop, satelites, ...} at roughly 1Hz. It has two logging modes: basic and advanced, allowing you to control which GPS properties are logged. The voice-memo feature is really slick. If you've ever stared at a map filled with Wayponts and POIs and forgotten what each of them meant then you know how valuable of a feature this is. If you do a lot of hiking, this feature is especially handy. The v900 saves each voice-memo as a .wav file on the microSD card and makes a link to it in the log file as a special waypoint. The audio quality isn't half bad, either!

Columbus v900 TimeAlbum screenshot
TimeAlbum 1.5: The Columbus v900 conversion software is java-based and runs on Windows, Mac & Linux.

If you're running mapping software on your laptop or PDA, then you'll be able to make good use of the SPP Bluetooth connection. As I mentioned before, you can't download log files via Bluetooth, which is a little unfortunate, but if you're in the market for an all-in-one device, then the v900 does offer GPS-mouse ability through NMEA format over bluetooth. If you're on a mac, you can use gps2gex to pipeline the NMEA data directly into Google Earth, or any other mapping/navigation software. It's pretty basic, but its free.

The Columbus v900 has a fairly unique feature, called “SPY mode” which allows continuous standby logging for up to a month! The device will go to sleep for a user-configurable amount of time before turning back on, re-establishing a signal, dropping a waypoint and shutting down again. Smart stuff.

The v900 also offers a few other minor features, such as auto-on/auto-off car mode, overspeed alarm and USB charging. Its internal 1000mAh battery holds a 24-hour charge and recharges via USB in roughly 4 hours. All told, it's an impressive set of features, and puts the Columbus v900 right up in the league of some of the pricey Garmin loggers, but at a VERY competitive price.

MTK vs. SiRF III

The Columbus v900 is the first MTK-based GPS logger I've been able to spend any decent time with, so I couldn't resist a few head-to-heads with my other SiRF III loggers.

MTK vs SiRF III on Google earth
head-to-head: MTK & SiRF III-based data loggers @ 1Hz-interval logging through the Songshan district in Taipei, Taiwan on Google Earth.

The v900's MTK chipset uses an active (amplified) antenna, which seemed to give it a very slight advantage in TTFF over other passive devices, such as the SiRF III (time-to-first-fix), especially in urban environments.

In open sky, both MTK and SiRF III chipsets achieved a near-perfect 30-35 second TTFF (as expected), but in the most extreme situations (such as indoors, aboard trains or driving around in the middle of downtown Taipei) the MTK device performed slightly better, achieving its first fix (from cold start) an average of 7-8 seconds faster over the course of 5 extremely rigorous tests in challenging urban environments. The SiRF III chipset, however, appeared to handle signal reflections and position drift slightly better, and would stay an average of 2-3 meters truer during a sample set of 5 extreme urban situations.

Conclusions

I've come to greatly enjoy the convenience of the v900's internal battery over the rechargeable batteries I've become accustomed to dragging around with me for all my older GPS data loggers. The v900's 1000mAh internal battery is more than enough for a full day of logging and its USB charging is plenty fast. You can recharge your v900 in the car, using the 12v car adapter that's included in the box or if you have a solar USB charger or a mintyboost, you can even recharge on the go. Either way, you'll never have to worry about depleting the internal battery away from home.

The Columbus v900 is the only GPS logger that I actually prefer to keep safely tucked away in my pocket instead of bouncing around on a carabiner, clipped to my bag. It's by far the smallest GPS logger I've ever used, and it feels solid in the hand. At first, it seemed a little frustrating to have to eject the microSD card every time I wanted to download the log files, but it became easy to rationalize, as at least I wasn't fumbling with rechargeable batteries like I was with my old GPS units; besides, I keep a keychain microSD card reader attached to the v900's lanyard, so I always have a card reader nearby.

Overall, I'm very impressed with the Columbus v900. It quickly replaced all my old GPS devices as my primary GPS unit, thanks to both its feature-set and stunning design. You can order your Columbus v900 (+ free 1Gb microSD card) from http://www.buyGPSnow.com/ for a little under $100 US.

For more information, you can download the v900 manual (English) and TimeAlbum (v. 1.6, English) from the Columbus website (Chinese, simplified), or you can contact the folks at buyGPSnow.com for any product questions. They have been incredibly supportive with all of my questions during my evaluation of the v900.

And lastly, if you have any questions about the v900 or if there's anything I've missed in this review, you can always drop me a line in the comments section.

Subscribe to this article!

Want to be notified when new comments are posted to this article?
No problem!

Simply point your RSS reader to the Blog-Shmog.com Super Secret Comments RSS Feed. Syndicate content

Or for all you old-schoolers out there who still enjoy the warm, soothing tingle of freshly delivered e-mail to your inbox, you can subscribe to Grandma Shmog's Extra Old-Fashioned Blog-Shmog.com E-mail Notifications...

Just use the link below, and sign up to "watch" this post!

Comments

Mon, 03/02/2009 - 22:43

Hi Ted.
Forgive the delay in my response... Blog-Shmog.com suffered some database issues that kept me busy for a week.

I transferred the [.csv] file to the Album and converted it to a .kmz file and then clicked on it. A GE map came on with a lot of thin green lines and other information. One of the green lines is at least partially my track but it is difficult to distinguish it from the other lines.

If you only converted one .csv file, it should be the only track that shows up in Google Earth. If you are still seeing multiple tracks in GE, make sure you haven't loaded multiple KML or KMZ files, or alternatively try turning off some "Geographic Web" data in Google Earth, such as roads & borders... Maybe your data is getting confused with other Google Earth data.

I hope this helps, don't hesitate to contact me for more information.

KJ

Tue, 02/24/2009 - 00:44

Blogman

oh man,
that sucks dude...

I hope you can recover everything!

-Bman.

Wed, 02/18/2009 - 22:22

Ted

Thanks to all of you for the great information.

I just got the unit as a birthday present and it is not clear to me how do I display my tracks on a map. I transferred the .cvs file to the Album and converted it to a .kmz file and then clicked on it. A GE map came on with a lot of thin green lines and other information. One of the green lines is at least partially my track but it is difficult to distinguish it from the other lines.

Sat, 02/14/2009 - 14:15

Hi Reverse,

Sorry for the confusion. KMZ files are simply compressed KML files. If you change the extension of your KMZ file to .ZIP, you can unzip it and you'll get the KML file!

I'm glad you're enjoying the v900.
If you have any other questions regarding the unit, don't hesitate to ask!

KJ

Sat, 02/14/2009 - 06:59

Reverse

You state several times that the software converts to .kml, but the version I have only converts to one format: .kmz ?

Other than that, I really like this logger. I keep it in my coat pocket when I ride my motorcycle, and it records the data without any problem, while at the same time feeding my blackberry bluetooth-based data to upload my position to GPSed or Google Latitude; very cool!

Tue, 02/10/2009 - 01:06

Ludo

@Kevin Jaako

Sorry, i've put a "buggy" app.
Now, it's works !

PS : all .csv files of a day are put in one .gpx file.

Mon, 02/09/2009 - 13:51

Wangchun

I wrote a perl script to convert v900 .csv files to .gpx

http://contrib.exoweb.net/browser/geoutils/columbus.pl

Only support "advanced mode" currently.

Sat, 02/07/2009 - 20:13

Hi Ludo,

Thanks for sharing your application!

I tested it out on some CSV files, but had no luck. The application runs, but it doesn't want to open any of my CSV files. I tried both "simple" and "advanced" mode CSV files, but neither works.

I'm actually working on a download script of my own, but mine is a shell script, based on unix tools: rsync and sed. is this a cocoa app?

Let me know if there's anything I can do to help!

KJ

Sat, 02/07/2009 - 14:25

Ludo

Hi,

Just to be patient for a next version of timeAlbum (and to wait my VGPS900), i wrote VGPS-900toGPX a small soft for MacOS X to convert .csv tracks in .gpx and to easilly format the MicroSD Card in FAT16.

http://ludovic.thebault.free.fr/download/VGPS-900toGPX.zip

To test (i wrote it with only one .csv file).

Thu, 02/05/2009 - 23:16

Hi Alex, thanks for stopping by.

How easy is it to use this device to simply geotag my photos? I see a lot of complicated file conversion etc. I want something like this to work if I am to spend $100.

At the moment, it's a 3-step workflow. Hopefully, the new (GPX-enabled) version of TimeAlbum will cut this down to a 2-step process when it's released. At the moment, you have to download the v900's log files using TimeAlbum and save as KML. Then use GPSBabel to convert your KML file to GPX. Once that is done, use GPSPhotoLinker to link your photos to the GPX file. It's not a particularly difficult task, but it's definitely time consuming (at least until the new version of TimeAlbum is out!)

Anyone know of a free way to get a bluetooth GPS receiver to do turn by turn navigation on a mac with no internet?

At the moment, there isn't really any good navigation software out there for mac. There are a few (such as RouteBuddy which is A: not free. B: offers very few maps) but none of them really work the way they should.

Microsoft Streets and Trips is fairly decent navigation software for PC (and mac if you're running parallels or WMware) but it mainly has maps for N. America and a few for Europe.

You can check maps-gps-info.com for a listing of free Mac GPS software.

How accurate is this device? To the nearest meter?

Only on military-grade devices! Consumer-band GPS devices, such as the Columbus v900 can get you within about 3 meters, and only when conditions are good. Usually <5m is considered good for the city.

Hope this helps!

KJ

Thu, 02/05/2009 - 22:45

Hey,
Thanks for the clarification, Remco!

Do you think the voltage-sensing circuitry that drives the v900's auto-on/auto-off feature is also to blame for the lack of a download-via-USB function? I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts...

Cheers,

KJ

Wed, 02/04/2009 - 05:56

Alex

If I am to buy this I will be using a Mac. I use aperture an iPhoto '09.

How easy is it to use this device to simply geo tag my photo's? I see a lot of complicated file conversion etc. I want something like this to work if I am to spend $100.

Also, anyone know of a free way to get a bluetooth GPS receiver to do turn by turn navigation on a mac with no internet?

How accurate is this device? To the nearest meter?

Regards

Sun, 02/01/2009 - 19:15

Remco Meeder

I don't think the TimeAlbum software will ever be able to output NMEA strings since the V900 doesn't log the NMEA data.
So in order for the V900 and Time Album to output NMEA a firmware update is needed as well so that the V900 logs NMEA data.

Another thing they should correct in a firmware update is the altitude information, the current firmware doesn't take the geoID data into account. So at my home which is 15 meters above sea level it displays 50 meters...

also,
There are no instructions coming through to the unit from the USB charger.
There are two pins connected through a resistor which tells the unit to turn on.

Thu, 01/29/2009 - 13:48

John Macmillan

I just got one of these units delivered and when I try to connect via bluetooth my mac can see the device but I get the following message "This Device Does Not Have The Necessary Services" so it will not connect. I have an email request in to the vendor to see if they have a resolution

update: (30/01/2009)

The vendor gave me some info on how to set up Bluetooth to work with this device. The problem has been resolved!

Tue, 01/27/2009 - 14:24

Hi Gustav.

Can the unit be charged with a normal mini USB charger, or is there something special with the charger (to make auto on-off work)? (It was reported in GpsPasSion that normal USB chargers did not work.)

The Columbus v900 will charge from any 5v (300mA+) source -be it a wall adapter, a 12v car adapter, solar charger, computer, etc.

However, the v900's auto on-off feature (car mode) will only work with the Columbus car adapter provided with the unit. My guess is there's some type of proprietary protocol or voltage trigger being sent over the 2 USB data lines from the Columbus car charger that the v900 understands, enabling car mode. It's a very desirable feature because it prevents the v900 from turning on every time you charge it at home... Many older-generation GPS dataloggers turn on every time you plug them into your computer. (on the other hand, I have a hunch that whatever signal tells car mode to turn on is also the reason why the Columbus v900 can't mount as a USB drive when you plug it into your computer; Just a hunch, though...)

update: (05/02/2009)

Remco Meeder later pointed out that the communication between the Columbus v900 and the car-charger is indeed based on a simple voltage, not a protocol.

Hope this helps!

KJ

Tue, 01/27/2009 - 01:49

Gustav

Can the unit be charged with a normal mini USB charger, or is there something special with the charger (to make auto on-off work)? (It was reported in GpsPasSion that normal USB chargers did not work.)

Thu, 01/15/2009 - 18:36

Thanks for the news, Davide.

The next version of Time Album (due probably the next month) will export in other formats NMEA, etc...

WOOOHOOO!!!!
Thanks fantastic news, thanks for the update.
I'll be sure to update my review once Columbus releases the new version.

KJ

Thu, 01/15/2009 - 16:00

Davide Rivola

I contacted the guys from Columbus. The next version of Time Album (due probably the next month) will export in other formats NMEA, etc...

Mon, 01/12/2009 - 21:10

Hi Chris. Thanks for stopping by...

Saw on the BuyGPSNow website an FAQ that pointed to the following site for a converter of the CSV files: http://bt747.free.fr/content/ Would be interested to know how well that works.

Yes, I have used bt747 for converting .CSV files. However, although it does appear to work with v900 log files, the interface is really bad and it only supports conversion of one file at a time. Personally, I much prefer using the Columbus-supplied software, TimeAlbum to download to KML and then using GPSBabel to convert to any other format I might need (including GPX).

To its credit, BT747 does offer a variety of file formats for converting to, including KML, NMEA and GPX. So if you don't mind rolling up your sleeves and dealing with some questionable open-source software, you should definitely check out bt747 and decide for yourself which works best for you.

Cheers,
KJ

Mon, 01/12/2009 - 12:26

Chris

Saw on the BuyGPSNow website an FAQ that pointed to the following site for a converter of the CSV files: http://bt747.free.fr/content/

Would be interested to know how well that works.

Thanks for the review! :-)

Thu, 01/08/2009 - 09:43

xdr

Thanks for that informative review. I've just ordered one from BuyGpsNow to help geocode my photos.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
Rawr! de$tr0y spamz0rs!!
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters (without spaces) shown in the image.